Law study notes
Arbitration · China · Platform liability

1. International commercial arbitration basics

Arbitration is private dispute resolution that rests on the parties' agreement and ends in a binding award that courts will enforce. Four ideas carry most of the subject: consent, separability, the seat, and a small mandatory floor of fairness.

Consent: no agreement, no arbitration

Arbitration needs an agreement to arbitrate. The New York Convention requires states to recognise an "agreement in writing" to submit disputes to arbitration (NYC Art. II(1)), and the Model Law defines the arbitration agreement and its form in Art. 7. China's revised law says the same thing in its own words: parties who choose arbitration must follow the principle of voluntariness and conclude an arbitration agreement, and without one the institution must decline the case (PRC Arbitration Law 2025, Art. 4).

Courts back the agreement up. A court seized of a matter covered by a valid arbitration agreement must refer the parties to arbitration at a party's request, unless the agreement is "null and void, inoperative or incapable of being performed" (NYC Art. II(3); Model Law Art. 8(1), where the request must come no later than the first statement on the substance).

Separability and competence-competence

An arbitration clause is treated as a separate agreement from the contract it sits in, so a claim that the main contract is void does not automatically destroy the clause. The tribunal may also rule on its own jurisdiction (Model Law Art. 16(1)). The same idea appears in PRC Arbitration Law 2025 Art. 30 and CIETAC Rules 2024 Art. 5(4). In China, SPC Guiding Case No. 196 (Yunyu) applied separability where the main contract had never been formed.

Party autonomy over procedure

The parties decide how the arbitration is run, and the tribunal fills the gaps:

"Subject to the provisions of this Law, the parties are free to agree on the procedure to be followed by the arbitral tribunal in conducting the proceedings."UNCITRAL Model Law, Art. 19(1)

Failing agreement, the tribunal may conduct the arbitration "in such manner as it considers appropriate" (Art. 19(2)). In practice parties rarely design a procedure from scratch. They pick an institution's rules, which give the tribunal wide case-management powers unless the parties agree otherwise (for example ICC Rules 2021 Arts. 19, 22 and 24; LCIA Rules 2020 Art. 14; SHIAC Rules 2024 Art. 39; CIETAC Rules 2024 Art. 35).

Evidence is often handled through soft-law instruments that parties opt into. The IBA Rules on the Taking of Evidence (2020) aim at an efficient, economical and fair process, "particularly" between parties "from different legal traditions", and are designed to supplement the rules the parties have chosen (Preamble, para. 1). The Prague Rules (2018) were drafted by a working group from mainly civil-law countries to encourage tribunals to take a more active role in managing proceedings.

The mandatory floor: equality and a fair hearing

"The parties shall be treated with equality and each party shall be given a full opportunity of presenting his case."UNCITRAL Model Law, Art. 18

This is the core that party agreement cannot remove. It reappears at the enforcement stage: an award can be refused if a party "was otherwise unable to present his case" (NYC Art. V(1)(b)).

The seat (place of arbitration)

The parties are free to agree on the place of arbitration (Model Law Art. 20(1)). The seat is a legal choice, not just a venue. It decides which arbitration law (the lex arbitri) applies and which courts supervise the arbitration and hear applications to set the award aside (Model Law Arts. 1(2) and 34). Hearings can still be held elsewhere (Model Law Art. 20(2)). If the parties have not chosen a seat, institutional rules supply a default: see the comparison table.

Law applicable to the merits

The tribunal decides the dispute under the rules of law chosen by the parties (Model Law Art. 28(1)). It may decide ex aequo et bono (on fairness rather than law) "only if the parties have expressly authorized it to do so" (Art. 28(3)). Compare ICC Rules 2021 Art. 21.

Challenging the award at the seat

Under the Model Law, setting aside is the exclusive recourse against an award (Art. 34). The grounds mirror the New York Convention refusal grounds, and the application must normally be made within three months of receiving the award (Art. 34(3)). The courts of other countries do not set the award aside. They only decide whether to recognise and enforce it there (see section 4).

Exam checklist

← HomeInstitutions →