2. Comparison of institutional rules
Most international arbitrations run under an institution's rules. The five sets below are the ones you meet most often in China-related work. The table compares the defaults that matter when a clause says nothing.
Versions: CIETAC Rules 2024 (effective 1 Jan 2024), SHIAC Arbitration Rules 2024 (effective 1 Jan 2024), HKIAC Administered Arbitration Rules 2024 (effective 1 Jun 2024), ICC Arbitration Rules 2021, LCIA Arbitration Rules 2020. Links on the Sources page.
| Rules | Seat if the parties are silent | Emergency arbitrator | Expedited / summary procedure | Joinder | Consolidation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CIETAC 2024 | The domicile of CIETAC or of the sub-commission/arbitration center administering the case; CIETAC may choose another place (Art. 7(2)). The award is deemed made at the seat (Art. 7(3)). | Available under the Emergency Arbitrator Procedures in Appendix III; the decision binds the parties (Art. 23(2)). | Summary Procedure (Ch. IV, Art. 59 ff.) applies where the amount in dispute does not exceed RMB 5,000,000 unless the parties agree otherwise, or above that with both parties' agreement (Art. 59(1)). | A party may request joinder of an additional party prima facie bound by the arbitration agreement invoked (Art. 18(1)). | CIETAC may consolidate at a party's request where claims arise under the same agreement, under identical or compatible agreements in related contracts, or where all parties agree (Art. 19(1)). |
| SHIAC 2024 | The domicile of SHIAC; SHIAC may entrust the tribunal to fix another place (Art. 7(2)). | A party may apply for an emergency arbitrator between acceptance of the case and constitution of the tribunal (Art. 25(1)). | Summary Procedures apply where the amount does not exceed RMB 5,000,000, above that with the parties' written consent, or where the clause calls for summary or expedited proceedings (Art. 69(1)). | Joinder of third parties under the same arbitration agreement, decided by the Secretariat before the tribunal is formed and by the tribunal afterwards (Art. 41(1)). | The tribunal may consolidate related or same-kind cases on a party's request with the consent of the other parties (Art. 40(1)). |
| HKIAC 2024 | Hong Kong, unless the tribunal decides that another seat is more appropriate (Art. 14.1). | Emergency Relief before the tribunal is constituted, under Schedule 4 (Art. 23.1). | Expedited Procedure on application before the tribunal is formed if the amount is below the threshold on HKIAC's website, the parties agree, or in cases of exceptional urgency (Art. 42.1). In principle a sole arbitrator (Art. 42.2). | The tribunal (or HKIAC before it is formed) may join a party prima facie bound by an arbitration agreement under the Rules, or where all parties agree (Art. 27.1). | HKIAC may consolidate where the parties agree, all claims arise under the same agreement, or (with compatible agreements) common questions arise from the same or related transactions (Art. 28.1). Single arbitration under multiple contracts: Art. 29. |
| ICC 2021 | Fixed by the ICC Court unless agreed by the parties (Art. 18(1)). | Emergency Arbitrator Rules in Appendix V for urgent measures that cannot await the tribunal (Art. 29(1)). | Expedited Procedure Provisions (Art. 30 and Appendix VI) apply automatically below the Appendix VI threshold (US$ 3 million for arbitration agreements concluded on or after 1 Jan 2021), or by agreement; they take precedence over contrary terms of the clause (Art. 30(1)–(2)). | Request for Joinder to the Secretariat; no joinder after confirmation or appointment of any arbitrator unless all parties agree or Art. 7(5) applies (Art. 7(1)). | The ICC Court may consolidate where the parties agree, claims are under the same agreement(s), or (different agreements) same parties, same legal relationship and compatible agreements (Art. 10). |
| LCIA 2020 | London, unless and until the tribunal orders that another seat is more appropriate (Art. 16.2). | Emergency Arbitrator under Art. 9B, unless the parties opted out or concluded their agreement before 1 Oct 2014 without opting in (Art. 9.16). | No separate expedited track; expedited formation of the tribunal in cases of exceptional urgency (Art. 9A) and the tribunal's power to expedite the procedure, including Early Determination (Arts. 14.6, 22.1(viii)). | The tribunal may join third persons only where the third person and the applicant party consent expressly in writing (Art. 22.1(x)). | Tribunal (with LCIA Court approval) or LCIA Court may consolidate where all parties agree in writing, or under the same or compatible agreements between the same parties or from the same transaction(s) (Arts. 22.7–22.8). |
What to take from the table
- Silence on the seat is costly. Under the mainland rules the default seat is the institution's own domicile (CIETAC Art. 7(2); SHIAC Art. 7(2)), so a clause naming CIETAC or SHIAC alone will usually mean a mainland seat and mainland court supervision. HKIAC and LCIA default to their home cities but let the tribunal pick another seat; ICC leaves it to the Court.
- Expedited procedures are often automatic. CIETAC, SHIAC and ICC switch to the faster track below a value threshold unless the parties agree otherwise. HKIAC needs an application.
- Consent matters most for multi-party cases. LCIA joinder requires express written consent by the third person, and SHIAC consolidation requires the other parties' consent. CIETAC, HKIAC and ICC allow joinder or consolidation on a prima facie or compatibility test.
- Party modifications of the rules. The parties' agreed changes to the rules prevail unless inoperative or contrary to a mandatory provision of the law of the seat (SHIAC Art. 4(2)) or of the law applicable to the proceedings (CIETAC Art. 4(3)). An agreement to arbitrate "under these Rules" without naming an institution is treated as a choice of SHIAC (SHIAC Art. 4(5)) or of CIETAC (CIETAC Art. 4(4)), which matters because Chinese law requires a selected institution (see section 3).
- Language. CIETAC defaults to Chinese if the parties have not agreed (Art. 84(2)); under SHIAC the Secretariat sets a preliminary language and the tribunal decides the final one (Art. 84(2)).
Not covered
SIAC (Singapore) is often compared too. Its 2025 Rules (7th ed.) were not fully checked for these notes, so they are left out of the table.