5. Governing law of the arbitration agreement
An arbitration clause is a separate agreement, so it can be governed by a different law from the main contract. Which law applies decides whether the clause is valid, what it covers and who it binds. England, China and Switzerland now answer the question in different ways.
England (1): Enka v Chubb [2020] UKSC 38
At para. 170 the UK Supreme Court summarised its approach for English conflict-of-laws purposes:
- The law of the arbitration agreement is the law chosen by the parties to govern it or, absent a choice, the law with which it is most closely connected (para. 170(ii)).
- Where the arbitration agreement has no specified law, a choice of law for the main contract will generally apply to the arbitration agreement too (para. 170(iv)), and choosing a seat in a different country does not by itself negate that inference (para. 170(v)).
- That inference can be displaced, for example where the seat's law treats the arbitration agreement as governed by that law, or where there is a serious risk the clause would be ineffective under the main contract's law (para. 170(vi)).
- With no choice of law at all, the arbitration agreement is governed by the law of closest connection, which will generally be the law of the seat (para. 170(viii)). On the facts, the contract had no choice of law, so the law of the seat (England) governed (para. 171).
England (2): Arbitration Act 2025
Section 1 of the Arbitration Act 2025 inserts a new s. 6A into the Arbitration Act 1996:
"The law applicable to an arbitration agreement is— (a) the law that the parties expressly agree applies to the arbitration agreement, or (b) where no such agreement is made, the law of the seat of the arbitration in question."Arbitration Act 1996, s. 6A(1), as inserted by Arbitration Act 2025, s. 1
Crucially, a choice of law for the main contract "does not constitute express agreement" that the same law applies to the arbitration agreement (s. 6A(2)). This reverses the main-contract presumption of Enka para. 170(iv): unless the parties expressly choose a law for the clause, the seat's law governs. The rule does not apply to arbitration agreements derived from standing offers in treaties or foreign legislation, as in investment arbitration (s. 6A(3)). Check the commencement provisions for which arbitrations the new rule covers.
China
- Conflicts Law 2010, Art. 18 (Law on the Application of Laws to Foreign-related Civil Relations): the parties may choose the law of the arbitration agreement; absent a choice, the law of the place where the arbitration institution is located or the law of the seat applies.
- SPC Provisions 法释〔2017〕22号, Art. 13: a choice must be made expressly; agreeing only on the law of the contract does not count as choosing the law of the arbitration clause. This anticipates the English 2025 position.
- Same Provisions, Art. 14: where there is no choice and the law of the institution's location and the law of the seat would give different answers on validity, the court applies the law that makes the agreement valid (a validation principle).
- Art. 15 lets the institution or seat be identified through the agreed arbitration rules.
Switzerland
For international arbitrations seated in Switzerland, an arbitration agreement is valid if it complies with the law chosen by the parties, the law governing the dispute (in particular the main contract), or Swiss law (Swiss PILA Art. 178(2)). This is an alternative-reference validation rule. Note that PILA Art. 187 deals with the law applicable to the merits, not the arbitration agreement.
Institutional rules
LCIA Rules 2020 Art. 16.4: the law applicable to the arbitration agreement and the arbitration is the law of the seat unless the parties have agreed in writing on other laws and that agreement is not prohibited by the seat's law. The HKIAC model clause includes an optional line for the law of the arbitration clause.
Comparison in one line each
- England (Enka): main-contract law generally governs the clause.
- England (AA 2025 s. 6A): express choice for the clause, otherwise the seat.
- China: express choice, otherwise institution or seat law, preferring whichever validates.
- Switzerland: valid if valid under any of three laws.
Drafting tip: state the law of the arbitration agreement expressly in the clause.