Law study notes
Arbitration · China · Platform liability

6. IP: platform and ISP liability

When a user uploads infringing content or sells counterfeits, is the platform liable? China, the EU and the US share the same basic model, notice-and-takedown with conditional safe harbours, but differ on timing, counter-notices and what counts as knowledge.

China

Civil Code (民法典), Arts. 1194–1197

E-Commerce Law 2018 (电子商务法), Arts. 41–45 and 84

The Civil Code rules are general (all civil rights, all network service providers); the E-Commerce Law rules are specific to IP on e-commerce platforms. The most visible difference is the fixed 15-day period (E-Commerce Law Art. 43) against the Civil Code's "reasonable period" (Art. 1196).

European Union: Digital Services Act (Regulation (EU) 2022/2065)

United States: DMCA safe harbours (17 U.S.C. § 512)

Comparison

IssueChinaEU (DSA)US (DMCA)
ScopeCivil Code: all civil rights. E-Commerce Law: IP on e-commerce platforms.All illegal content (horizontal).Copyright only.
Knowledge standard"Knows or should know" (CC Art. 1197; ECL Art. 45).Actual knowledge or awareness (Art. 6(1)).Actual knowledge or red-flag awareness (§ 512(c)(1)(A)).
Effect of failing to act on noticeJoint and several liability for the extended damage (CC Art. 1195; ECL Art. 42).The hosting exemption no longer applies (Art. 6(1)(b)).The safe harbour no longer applies (§ 512(c)(1)(C)).
Counter-notice and restorationReasonable period (CC Art. 1196); 15 days on e-commerce platforms (ECL Art. 43).Not covered by Arts. 6, 8 and 16 (outside these notes).Counter-notification procedure (§ 512(g)).
General monitoringNot expressly addressed in these articles.Prohibited as a general obligation (Art. 8).Not a condition of the safe harbour (§ 512(m)).
Wrongful noticesLiability; double compensation for bad faith on e-commerce platforms (ECL Art. 42).Notices must include a good-faith statement (Art. 16(2)(d)).Notice must include good-faith and accuracy statements (§ 512(c)(3)).

Essay angles to think about

Texts checked: Civil Code Arts. 1194–1197 (official Chinese text), E-Commerce Law Arts. 41–45 and 84 (NPC English translation), DSA Arts. 6, 8 and 16, and 17 U.S.C. § 512. See Sources.

← Governing lawGlossary →