6. IP: platform and ISP liability
When a user uploads infringing content or sells counterfeits, is the platform liable? China, the EU and the US share the same basic model, notice-and-takedown with conditional safe harbours, but differ on timing, counter-notices and what counts as knowledge.
China
Civil Code (民法典), Arts. 1194–1197
- Art. 1194: network users and network service providers who use the network to infringe others' civil rights bear tort liability.
- Art. 1195 (notice): the right holder may notify the provider to take "necessary measures" such as deletion, blocking or disconnecting links. The notice must include prima facie evidence of infringement and the right holder's real identity. The provider must promptly forward it to the user and take necessary measures based on the evidence and the type of service. If it fails to act in time, it is jointly and severally liable with the user for the extended part of the damage. A right holder who sends a wrongful notice is liable for the resulting harm.
- Art. 1196 (counter-notice): the user may submit a declaration of non-infringement with prima facie evidence and its real identity. The provider forwards it and tells the right holder it may complain to the authorities or sue. If no notice of a complaint or lawsuit arrives within a reasonable period, the provider must promptly end the measures.
- Art. 1197 (knowledge): a provider that knows or should know that a user is infringing and fails to take necessary measures is jointly and severally liable with the user.
E-Commerce Law 2018 (电子商务法), Arts. 41–45 and 84
- Art. 41: e-commerce platform operators must formulate IP-protection rules and cooperate with right holders.
- Art. 42: notice with prima facie evidence; the platform must take timely necessary measures (including terminating transactions and services) and forward the notice, or be jointly and severally liable for the further damage. Wrongful notices attract civil liability, and bad-faith wrongful notices double compensation.
- Art. 43: counter-declaration with prima facie evidence of non-infringement; the platform must end its measures if it receives no notice of a complaint or lawsuit within 15 days after the declaration reaches the right holder.
- Art. 44: the platform must publish notices, declarations and the results.
- Art. 45: knows-or-should-have-known liability, mirroring Civil Code Art. 1197.
- Art. 84: administrative fines for platforms that fail to take necessary measures under Arts. 42 or 45.
The Civil Code rules are general (all civil rights, all network service providers); the E-Commerce Law rules are specific to IP on e-commerce platforms. The most visible difference is the fixed 15-day period (E-Commerce Law Art. 43) against the Civil Code's "reasonable period" (Art. 1196).
European Union: Digital Services Act (Regulation (EU) 2022/2065)
- Arts. 4–6: liability exemptions for "mere conduit", caching and hosting services, carried over from the e-Commerce Directive.
- Art. 6(1) (hosting): a host is not liable for information stored at a user's request if it does not have actual knowledge of illegal content (and, for damages claims, is not aware of facts or circumstances making it apparent), or acts expeditiously to remove or disable access once it obtains such knowledge or awareness.
- Art. 6(2)–(3): no exemption where the user acts under the provider's authority or control, nor, under consumer-protection law, where a marketplace presents an item so that an average consumer would believe the platform (or someone under its control) is providing it.
- Art. 8: no general obligation to monitor or to actively seek facts indicating illegal activity.
- Art. 16 (notice and action): hosts must offer an easy electronic notice mechanism. A notice should contain a substantiated explanation, the exact location (e.g. URL), the notifier's name and email (with exceptions), and a good-faith statement. A notice that lets a diligent provider identify the illegality "without a detailed legal examination" gives rise to actual knowledge for Art. 6.
United States: DMCA safe harbours (17 U.S.C. § 512)
- § 512(a)–(d): four safe harbours: transitory network communications, system caching, information stored at the direction of users, and information location tools. They limit liability for monetary relief and most injunctive relief for copyright infringement.
- § 512(c)(1) (hosting): the provider must lack actual knowledge and "red flag" awareness (facts or circumstances from which infringement is apparent), or act expeditiously to remove material once it knows. It must also not receive a financial benefit directly attributable to infringement it has the right and ability to control.
- § 512(c)(3): the elements of a valid takedown notice, sent to the provider's designated agent.
- § 512(g): no liability for good-faith takedown, plus a counter-notification procedure for material stored at a subscriber's direction.
- § 512(i): eligibility conditions: a repeat-infringer termination policy and accommodating standard technical measures.
- § 512(m): the safe harbours are not conditioned on monitoring the service.
Comparison
| Issue | China | EU (DSA) | US (DMCA) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scope | Civil Code: all civil rights. E-Commerce Law: IP on e-commerce platforms. | All illegal content (horizontal). | Copyright only. |
| Knowledge standard | "Knows or should know" (CC Art. 1197; ECL Art. 45). | Actual knowledge or awareness (Art. 6(1)). | Actual knowledge or red-flag awareness (§ 512(c)(1)(A)). |
| Effect of failing to act on notice | Joint and several liability for the extended damage (CC Art. 1195; ECL Art. 42). | The hosting exemption no longer applies (Art. 6(1)(b)). | The safe harbour no longer applies (§ 512(c)(1)(C)). |
| Counter-notice and restoration | Reasonable period (CC Art. 1196); 15 days on e-commerce platforms (ECL Art. 43). | Not covered by Arts. 6, 8 and 16 (outside these notes). | Counter-notification procedure (§ 512(g)). |
| General monitoring | Not expressly addressed in these articles. | Prohibited as a general obligation (Art. 8). | Not a condition of the safe harbour (§ 512(m)). |
| Wrongful notices | Liability; double compensation for bad faith on e-commerce platforms (ECL Art. 42). | Notices must include a good-faith statement (Art. 16(2)(d)). | Notice must include good-faith and accuracy statements (§ 512(c)(3)). |
Essay angles to think about
- Does "should know" in China push platforms toward proactive filtering, despite no express general-monitoring rule?
- Is a fixed 15-day window fairer to sellers or harsher on foreign right holders than a "reasonable period"?
- Should liability depend on the type of service (CC Art. 1195 refers to "the type of service") rather than a single hosting test?
Texts checked: Civil Code Arts. 1194–1197 (official Chinese text), E-Commerce Law Arts. 41–45 and 84 (NPC English translation), DSA Arts. 6, 8 and 16, and 17 U.S.C. § 512. See Sources.