Law study notes
Arbitration · China · Platform liability

4. Recognition and enforcement under the New York Convention

The 1958 Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards is why arbitration works across borders. A state party must recognise arbitration agreements and enforce foreign awards, and it may refuse only on a short, closed list of grounds.

Scope (Art. I)

The Convention applies to awards made in the territory of a state other than the one where enforcement is sought, and to awards not considered domestic in the enforcing state (Art. I(1)). On joining, a state may declare two reservations (Art. I(3)): reciprocity (it applies the Convention only to awards made in another Contracting State) and commercial (only to differences considered commercial under its national law).

The duty to enforce (Arts. III–IV)

Each Contracting State must recognise awards as binding and enforce them under its own procedural rules, without "substantially more onerous conditions or higher fees or charges" than for domestic awards (Art. III). The applicant supplies the authenticated original award or a certified copy, the original arbitration agreement or a certified copy, and certified translations where needed (Art. IV).

Grounds for refusal (Art. V)

Recognition "may be refused ... only if" one of these grounds is shown. Under Art. V(1) the party resisting enforcement must prove the ground; the Art. V(2) grounds turn on what the enforcing court itself finds.

GroundContent
V(1)(a)Incapacity of a party, or the agreement is invalid under the law the parties chose or, failing that, the law of the country where the award was made.
V(1)(b)No proper notice of the arbitrator's appointment or the proceedings, or the party was otherwise unable to present its case.
V(1)(c)The award goes beyond the submission to arbitration; the part within it can be enforced if it can be separated.
V(1)(d)The tribunal's composition or the procedure was not in accordance with the parties' agreement or, failing such agreement, the law of the country where the arbitration took place.
V(1)(e)The award is not yet binding, or has been set aside or suspended by a competent authority of the country in which, or under the law of which, it was made.
V(2)(a)The subject matter is not capable of settlement by arbitration under the law of the enforcing country.
V(2)(b)Enforcement would be contrary to the public policy of the enforcing country.

Reading V(1)(d) correctly

The text puts the parties' agreement first. The law of the seat governs composition and procedure only "failing such agreement". The seat's mandatory law bites in other ways: through setting aside at the seat (which then triggers V(1)(e)) and through the due-process and public-policy grounds (V(1)(b), V(2)(b)).

Other provisions worth knowing

Links to the Model Law and Chinese law

Model Law Art. 36 repeats the Art. V grounds for refusing enforcement "irrespective of the country in which it was made", and Art. 34 uses the same list for setting aside at the seat. In China, PRC Arbitration Law 2025 Art. 88 tells parties which intermediate people's court to apply to for enforcement of a foreign award and requires the court to apply treaties or reciprocity. Under SPC Provisions 法释〔2017〕22号 Art. 16, a validity objection to the arbitration agreement in a Convention case is decided under Art. V(1)(a).

← China 2025Governing law →